Worst Film Ever

Written by  //  January 13, 2011  //  Symposium, The Table  //  17 Comments

Gather round our round table of truthiness, where the Donnybrook Elite and our esteemed blog-friends debate which is the shittiest, shittiest shitty movie ever made.

Our guest bloggers this week include Matt Jordan from You Ain’t No Picasso, Ethan Axelrod, Denver editor of the Huffington Post, Lawrence Dai from the Lawrence/Julie & Julia Project, and Alice Hubley from The Shins Will Change Your Life – not to mention Angora, Fritz, and Professor Honeydew from Donnybrook. Let the voting commence!

Garden State

Professor Honeydew’s Pick

“What are you listening to?”

“The Shins. You know ‘em?”


“You gotta hear this one song–it’ll change your life, I swear.”

OMG! <3 x 1,000,000!!!

It’s a shame there aren’t Academy Award categories for feats such as Laziest Attempt at a Screenplay or Most Pretentious Failure at Being an Auteur, because Zach Braff would’ve needed a wheelbarrow to cart off his Oscars in 2005.

There are some movies you walk out of feeling like an idiot for having wasted two hours of your life (Charlie Bartlett, anyone?). However, Garden State tops them all: you can actually feel yourself growing appreciably less intelligent with each flickering frame that passes before your eyes.

The most impressive performance in this film is delivered by a restaurant–Sea, Williamsburg’s haute Thai emporium–and, go figure, even that it isn’t in the real Garden State.

Like a grotesque car accident that leaves you with a paralyzed arm and shitting yourself uncontrollably, Garden State will change your life. I swear.

Honorable Mention: (500) Days of Summer; Juno; Paul Blart: Mall Cop.

Taking Lives

Matt’s Pick (from You Ain’t No Picasso)

I’ve hated this movie from about 30 minutes into my first and only viewing of it in a theater in Elizabethtown, KY in 2004. In fact, this movie is probably why I don’t care for Angelina Jolie to this day. I get very, very angry about obvious plot oversights in films and this movie is full of ‘em. Since I’m limited to a paragraph, I’ll just share my favorite: at one point the cops have one suspect and one witness (the killer’s mom) who can positively identify the man they’re looking for. While in holding, the suspect draws a picture of the person he says is the murderer. So naturally the cops take that drawing to the witness and upon receiving word that this drawing looks nothing like her son, they let the only suspect (who the witness never met) go free. Gee, I wonder who the killer is? Avoid this one unless you’re looking for a movie to make you yell at the screen for an hour and a half.

Citizen Kane

Lawrence’s Pick (from The Lawrence/Julie & Julia Project)

I’ve got a bone to pick with you, Citizen Kane. Sure, you may have everyone else on your side—The American Film Institute, Roger Ebert, general consensus—but you don’t have me fooled. Not one bit. People love to say that you’re the greatest film of all time, but to be honest? I think you’re the worst.

First of all, I’d like to point out that there’s this thing called color. Ever heard of it? Sorry to break it to you, but most movies these days are made in color. You know, because that’s how most people see the world—in color. So take your pretentious black & white photography and shove it up your ass, because your dull, colorless world bores me to tears. And speaking of boring, can you really justify this two-hour running time? You seriously expect me to sit still for two whole hours? It only takes two minutes to watch a hilarious Youtube video of a cat licking itself, not to mention that cat movies are way more entertaining/in color. At least give me a chance to take a breather here and there. Have you thought about adding in some commercial breaks? You’d probably make more money that way too, considering I don’t know how the hell you’re going to sell tickets to this snoozefest in the first place.

And the content—yeesh. Movies aren’t supposed to be about important things. Duh. Do I really want to see the rise and fall of an American business mogul? No, I want to see Jessica Alba in a bikini. I think that’s pretty obvious. And even if I wanted to watch bullshit political drama, I’d just turn on CSPAN, which is probably more exciting anyways. Where are the car chases, the gunfights, the explosions, the space lasers? I mean, the only person who dies in the entire movie is Charles Foster Kane—and he dies in his sleep. How lame is that? Would it really be that hard to have someone stab or shoot him? Or what about a passionate love scene, where Susan Alexander sexes him to death? Now that would’ve been cool. But noooo, you insisted on drawing out his death in the least interesting way possible. And then you threw that whole “Rosebud” thing in there, thinking it would be this big “twist” and we’d all get suckered into your stupid story. Well, I’ve got news for you, chief—revealing that “Rosebud” is the sled from Kane’s childhood isn’t a twist—it’s a huge fucking copout.

I don’t care that you basically invented deep focus shots. I don’t care that you revolutionized the flashback narrative form. I don’t care that you gave Orson Welles the performance of a lifetime. I care that you refuse to hold my hand as a viewer and fail to provide instant gratification for each and every second. Dammit, I deserve better. The American people deserve better.

Citizen Kane, you are the worst movie ever.

I Heart Huckabees

Ethan Axelrod’s pick (from Huffington Post)

OK, so maybe I Heart Huckabees isn’t the ‘worst movie of all time.’ I’ll even concede that it has its mildly amusing moments.

But, personally, I’ve listened to people fawn over this film for way too long, and—presented with opportunity to publicly rip a movie—it’s a natural choice. I’m tired of people acting as if this movie represents some transcendent fusion of philosophy and comedy. The conflict between interconectedeness and nihilism that comprises—on some level, I guess—the central dilemma of the whole movie is poorly-defined throughout. Plus, all of these themes about ambitiousness and idealism are fine to frame a movie, but there’s nothing particularly profound about the way they’re conveyed in this movie.

But failure make a profound philosophical/social statement is not a reason to hate a movie. What really sucks about I Heart Huckabees its self-awareness. The whole point of deadpan, dry comedy is to act unaware that what you’re saying could possibly be funny. Somehow this movie manages to take the opposite approach. Every line is delivered tongue-in-cheek as if it were going to be funny by default, or because it’s being spoken by a famous actor. There are exceptions (mostly involving Mark Wahlberg), but generally the movie undermines almost all of its own humor with this self-righteous assumption of its own cleverness.

It’s as if the writers of I Heart Huckabees did a focus group to determine exactly the type of dry, quirky comedy that white, college-educated Americans would eat up, then proceeded without even considering why people might like this.

The Godfather Part III

Fritz Godard’s Pick

What makes a great terrible movie is in the re-telling. When you tell people that Heaven’s Gate is a movie about a labor strike in the old west that just happens to have a scene devoted to fiddling and . . . wait for it . . . roller skating, these nonsensical scenes let the legend of terribleness spread.

My favorite scene like this comes in the epically terrible The Godfather Part III. The scene is when Jason Schwartzman’s mom decides that the family needs to kill Tuco from The Good, The Bad and the Ugly, and the best way to kill this sworn enemy of the Corleone’s? Why of course, a poison doughnut at the opera. The best part of the scene is Tuco dancing along to the opera while holding a doughnut. Now, we here at the DWA are not strangers to opera. Besides having an at-home opera theatre, we have board members on every opera house in the greater United States, but even with all the opera power, we still haven’t been able to get a Krispy Kreme vendor to walk from box to box selling his wares. Coppola, congrats on making a brilliantly crappy scene in a genuinely crappy movie.

The Wicker Man

Alice’s Pick (from The Shins Will Change Your Life)

Now I have to confess, I’m not really one to like “good movies.”  My idea of a good movie is something with Andrew McCarthy, or teenage SJP. There will be a robot, a wise-cracking underdog who steals the jock’s girlfriend, and if we’re lucky, a dog wearing sunglasses and a hat. To make me smile, the nerds will get their revenge, there will be a shy awkward Michael Cera/Jason Gordon Levitt-type quoting Smiths lyrics – and to top it off, a cameo from some unlikely celebrity. Now I think these are good movies, but my movie taste does get scoffed by many a film snob as being teenage, dumb and delusional. It’s all right, I can live with that.

One movie that I do like is The Wicker Man (the original). I remember the first time I saw it as a teenager, and I was gripped; you really felt for Edward Woodward’s character, and the end was a shock, the music is awesome, Christopher Lee was amazing etc etc. Basically you can’t argue with it, The Wicker Man is a bonafide “good movie” liked by movie snobs and ignoramuses like myself. Why the devil did Hollywood think it was a good idea to remake it?

One of the great things about the original Wicker Man is that it isn’t Hollywood – the Scottish accents and countryside kind of make it more believable, chilling and moving. The 2006 remake is set in middle America, instead of Scotland; Woodward’s character is played by Nicholas (Face Off!) Cage; and Lee is played by a woman, which I guess is pretty cool, though I guess they did that because no one could play the part as well as Lee. The remake changes the story so it doesn’t really make sense: they thought Nicholas Cage can’t be a virgin in this modern day (just look at that face! He looks just like John Travolta!) so they made up the storyline that the pagans must sacrifice someone who is connected to them, but not one of them, so ladies from the village go to bars in the local town pick up guys, get pregnant, and then months/years later reel them in to sacrifice them. The whole innocence of the Policeman character is lost, and instead replaced by this idiosyncratic love story where Cage is trying to convince the mother of his child to run away with him. You spent the whole of the original thinking, “oh come on just sleep with Britt Eckland and you could be saved,” but you spend the whole of the remaking thinking “at least I get to watch Nicholas Cage die” (though I was worried they’d change that too…).

At the end of the original, you do feel for the Policeman, and the despair and hopelessness of his character. At the end of the remake, I was more confused about why the film was dedicated to Johnny (the worst) Ramone, and also why I spent two hours watching that nonsense rather than feeling any emotion. I’m just glad that the storyline of Harold and Maude is so questionable that they wont remake that, oh god what bastardized creation could Hollywood come up with for that?

The Room

Angora Holly Polo’s Pick

There are nuanced reasons why the above films are horrible, but everyone unanimously agrees The Room is horrible. Let’s just get right into a top ten list of why it’s so bad:

10.) Johnny always ends scenes by putting his arm around someone and saying “Let’s go home” when they are already home.

9.) They reuse sex scene footage. That’s like reusing sex toys. Wait…these roses and silk bed curtains seem familiar…that’s because we saw them five minutes ago! Also, Johnny cackles while having sex. He actually cackles.

8.) An unattractive vixen is always humorous. It’s really funny to watch men fall over themselves for someone who is totally uggo.

7.) The men always toss a football back and forth when talking to other men. And they’re always like, two feet away from each other!

6.) How hysterical do you think Lisa gets when she finds out little Danny owes some dude drug money? Really hysterical. Hilariously hysterical. Why was that scene in there again?

5.) The gratuitous San Francisco skyline shots

4.) The mother dropping the “I’m Dying of Cancer” bomb casually in conversation, then moving on

3.) The scene where they’re all wearing tuxedos, then they go run around outside playing football, rough-house, and then it cuts away and you have no idea why they were wearing tuxedos


1.) You are tearing me apart, Lisa!


What is the worst film ever?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

About the Author

The Donnybrook Writing Academy

The Donnybrook Writing Academy is the visual personification of absolute perfection.

View all posts by

17 Comments on "Worst Film Ever"

  1. Etheral JB January 13, 2011 at 11:46 am · Reply

    I voted for The Godfather Part III. On top of the valid reasons stated by Mr. Goddard. Here are some more reasons why I hate that movie and also it sucks balls:

    - Sofia Coppola. In my opinion she is an over-rated writer/director, but let it never be said that she is anything more than a god awful actress.
    - Borderline incest between Coppola’s character and Andy Garcia’s. Weird.
    - No Robert Duvall. To explain this they went with the whole “sorry to hear about your dad dying” line.
    - The Airwolf helicopter assassination scene.
    - How do you kill an icon of American cinema? He falls out of his chair. CREDITS.

  2. Nina January 13, 2011 at 11:52 am · Reply

    To me, the Room is actually one of the most hilarious comedy movies of all time. Yes, it’s unintentional comedy, but so so glorious. Seriously, go watch it.

    My vote goes to Garden State. Barf and more barf.

  3. John Moore January 13, 2011 at 12:05 pm · Reply

    Red Dawn! Red Dawn! Red Dawn! Those cagey communists infiltrated American airspace — all the way to Colorado!! — and shot up one of our very own schoolyards. “You bastards!” That movie single-handedly scared the crap out of America into re-electing Reagan and Bush. That led to the ignoring of the AIDS crisis, the proliferation of the worthless Star Wars defense system, and the Wall Street/banking de-regulation that started the country down the crapper we’re in now. What more does a movie have to do? AND they’re re-making it. Red Dawn ! Red Dawn ! Red Dawn !

  4. Kathleen January 13, 2011 at 2:16 pm · Reply

    This list is nothing without “Troll 2.”

    Nonetheless, I cast my vote for “The Wicker Man.” I saw it once, and it captured my heart with its awfulness. Nic Cage delivers a gloriously overwrought performance, stealing bicycles, punching old lades and kicking ass in a bear suit.

    Fave lines: “How’d it get burned? How’d it get burned? HOW’DITGETBURNEDHOW’DITGETBURRRNED!!!!!!!”


  5. John Wenzel January 13, 2011 at 3:09 pm · Reply

    But can “Wicker Man” truly be bad when we derive so much joy from it??

  6. Lara January 13, 2011 at 3:44 pm · Reply

    With the exceptions of I Heart Huckabees and Citizen Kane, I actually haven’t seen any of these, but I voted for Garden State because I’ve been on three dates with three different guys in their mid-30′s recently, and they all, independently and without any kind of prompting, have told me how it’s their favorite movie, and as a result, The Shins is their favorite band.

    To me, this revelation has become shorthand for “Hi, I’m a boring, unimaginative white dude in perpetual adolescence who expects women to fulfill my lame, Natalie Portman fantasy that was cultivated 10 years ago.” What’s more disheartening is realizing just how many of those guys are out there in the dating pool.

    Fuck you, Garden State.

  7. Sir Nigel Hawthorne Creampispy III January 13, 2011 at 4:16 pm · Reply

    I voted for Godfather III. What a horrid way to follow two amazing movies. I actually kind of liked some parts of Garden State. However Lara’s response makes me glad that I don’t like the Shins, and while I think Natalie is very cute have, thankfully, never had a NP fantasy. (Call me Anakin! Call me Anakin!)

    In keeping with the current form: Fuck you, Godfather III

  8. Momma G January 14, 2011 at 9:09 am · Reply

    I’m sorry that “Brother from Another Planet” is not on the list. Although hilarious, unintentionally, it was a real dog of a movie. Something to contemplate for next year. Love you guys and gals!!


  9. campervans for sale November 7, 2013 at 6:19 pm · Reply

    Thanks for sharing your info. I truly appreciate your efforts
    and I will be waiting for your further write ups thanks once again.

    Also visit my web-site; campervans for sale

  10. windows data recovery software November 14, 2013 at 5:11 am · Reply

    Hello everyone, it’s my first go to see at this web page, and paragraph is actually fruitful in favor of me, keep up posting such articles or reviews.

  11. Sony Xperia Tablet Z November 19, 2013 at 5:12 pm · Reply

    I am really impressed with your writing skills and also with the layout on your blog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Anyway keep up the excellent quality writing, it’s rare to see a great blog like this one nowadays.

  12. new jordan releases November 24, 2013 at 9:48 pm · Reply

    There is no longer an excuse for such poor grammer. Try again hot shot!

    • Judge April 25, 2014 at 8:20 pm · Reply

      new jordan releases,
      I hope that you were joking when you wrote, “There is no longer an excuse for such poor grammer. Try again hot shot!” and spelled GRAMMAR incorrectly. If you weren’t kidding, you should have to sit through the movie “Dogma” until hell freezes over.

  13. frye boots on sale November 25, 2013 at 11:28 pm · Reply

    I am a failure when it comes to deciphering lyrics, but I am pretty sure Jim is trying to tell us about a fleeting moment of romance, “Faintest snow keep falling,/FALLING, yeah./Hands around your waist/NAMELESS, standing cold”.
    frye boots on sale http://2013hunterebay.webs.com/

  14. blog February 28, 2014 at 11:50 am · Reply

    Hello, you used to write great, but the last few posts have been kinda boringˇK I miss your super writings. Past few posts are just a bit out of track! come on!

  15. main home March 11, 2014 at 2:33 pm · Reply

    Yet another issue is that video gaming has become one of the all-time most important forms of entertainment for people spanning various ages. Kids engage in video games, and adults do, too. The XBox 360 is amongst the favorite games systems for individuals that love to have a huge variety of video games available to them, and who like to experiment with live with other individuals all over the world. Thank you for sharing your opinions.

  16. main page March 21, 2014 at 9:33 am · Reply

    Well I sincerely liked reading it. This post provided by you is very useful for accurate planning.

Leave a Comment

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

comm comm comm