III:The ten worst

Written by  //  January 25, 2008  //  Cinematical  //  9 Comments

Despite the fact the final installment of my end of the year post is shedding light on the worst films of the year, posting this list under the prestigious name of Donny Brook could have swayed Academy Members to consider these films for their jejune attempt at an award show. So, to avoid scandal I waited until the Academy announced the nominations to provide the 2008 dreadful contributions to cinema. 10. ZodiacDavid FincherFilm Comment loses credibility for naming this film the film of the year. Fincher’s heavy reliance on CGI to provide money shots is one of the many examples that computers are destroying creativity in Hollywood. The film drags, Jake Gyllenhaal’s the least convincing bookworm, Robert Downey Jr. plays Robert Downey Jr. with a different wardrobe, and the suspense scenes lack any bit of payoff. If Fincher wanted to make a film which showed how non-cinematic an actual police investigation is, he succeeded.Jonathan Rhys Meyers dramatic reunion with his bastard child9. August RushKristen Sheridan – The plot falls nicely into the category of mystical-sap. Jonathan Rhys Meyers is so wooden in this film I expected to see his stain chip when he attempted to smile. Robin Williams raises his ratio of good films:bad films to 1:20 with his Bono impression in the film.Shown reacting to a pie in the face and a giant novelty cane pulling someone off the stage.8. The SavagesTamara Jenkins – When I told people I hated this movie their immediate response was “Well, you like/laugh when you go through that.” I’m sorry I have to disagree even when I willingly put my parents in an old-folks home, I’m still sure I won’t laugh at jokes centered around the for Dummies line of books. There should be a public service announcement before the film: Warning – This film does contain not one second of original comedy in the movie, and any attempt at a genuine emotion from Hoffman or Linney is stifled by trying to jam the film in to the genre of bourgeoi-core. Thank you. Please enjoy the Concession stand.Nothing like a vacation in the states7. Seraphim FallsDavid Von Ancken – The westerns were doing so great this year, what happened with this? The film had a number of problems, but here are three: 1-Spending so much money on two foreign actors they weren’t able to hire dialect coaches; 2 – casting Pierce Brosnan to carry the majority of the movie (just try to imagine Castaway staring the old Bond instead of T. Hanks, I’m sure I wouldn’t even be able to get through a trailer for that movie); 3 – if you don’t have an ending, adding a surreal ending to a strait film is cheating, or lazy writing. Either way I can’t condone that.

This may be a clue to one of the plot holes6. The Number 23Joel Schumacher – I must be souring in my old age. This movie never had any aspirations to be more than a J. Carrey vehicle to fill seats when the giant blockbusters are sold out, so putting on the list seems like kicking a lame duck. Yet, here it is in all of its tacky cheaply written glory.

Can't. Sleep. Must. Text.5. The InvasionOliver Hirschbiegel – Boring! And also who cares. The simple rule for remakes should be if you can’t make it entirely better, not just add CGI, don’t make it.

No actors were used in the filming of this movie4. Fantastic 4: Rise of the Silver SurferTim Story – Again, putting this film on this list feels a little like cheating, the movie had no aspirations to be more than a money making vehicle to test the waters of a Silver Surfer franchise, but I’m taking a stand against bleak comic book movies. Hollywood is completely over-estimating the following of fan boys. In the beginning of comic book movies they wanted to have a quality director, quality script and actors not stars, but now, the talent has left the table and their banking on this guy and whoever the guy was who directed Ghost Rider. In the early days rumors flew that the franchise was to be directed by Steven Soderbergh and star George Clooney. That is the kind of world I want to live in.

None hotter.3. The Last LegionDoug Lefler – This movie is the most forgettable movie of the year. A joke of a joke of a film. It didn’t take long for the 300 knock offs to begin I thought when I first saw the trailer, but I assure you even the disposable comedy Meet the Spartans will have more cinematic credibility than this film. This would be number one if it wasn’t for the most beautiful girl in the world, Aishwarya Rai.

2. Illegal AlliensDavid Giancola – it is such a shame there was a huge debate over the rightful owner of Anna Nicole’s baby or this could have been the last thing the world would have to remember of Miss Smith. This film may be the second worst film of the year, but it was exponentially more entertaining than the next film.

Boys get ready to defend your good name.1. Across the Universe – I don’t even want to mention her name – The worst film of the year. The hatred for this film was incubated for weeks after the initial viewing. If I could advise Sir Mccartney and Mr. Starr I would suggest that they spend the rest of their fortune to block this movie from having a life after the theaters. The no-talent hack that directed this film has done nothing creative and simply exploited the most respected rock band of all time. It isn’t bad enough that Michael Jackson owns all the rights to Beatles songs, now the world has to suffer through a two hours of a hybrid that combines the worst music videos to the worst covers of the best songs of all time. This film should be a sign of the apocalypse. I just pray the invention from Eternal Sunshine is created, so I can invest in having this horrible movie erased from my memory banks.There it is. This post was like Pirates of the Carrabiean: At World’s End, Spider-man 3, and Shrek the Third all rolled into a giant ball of end of trilogy terrible-ness. Feel free to make any adjustments to you Netflix queue to avoid the pain of viewing these films.

About the Author

Fritz Godard

Fritz Godard is Donnybrook's film columnist, world-renowned filmmaker, and reason behind Marilyn Monroe's demise.

View all posts by

9 Comments on "III:The ten worst"

  1. Sid Pink January 25, 2008 at 3:02 am · Reply

    You’re probably right.
    Luckily, I saw exactly none of these movies.
    Still – reviews that go through the mystery of spell-check AND a once-over for grammar/syntax-murder have a lot more credibility.


    Uncle Sid

  2. robbiebowman January 25, 2008 at 8:18 am · Reply

    Wait a damn second! Zodiac and The Savages were worse than I Now Pronounce You Chuck and Larry or Pirates of the Carribean III or Rush Hour 3 or Transformers or Evan Almighty? How can you possibly think that? I am incredulous.

  3. Lady Z January 25, 2008 at 9:08 am · Reply

    Wha… wait… hey- why is Atonement not on this list???

  4. Lady Z January 25, 2008 at 9:09 am · Reply

    Holy fuck, Evan Almighty was the worst spent two hours of my whole fucking life…

  5. Col. Hector Bravado January 25, 2008 at 9:30 am · Reply

    I didn’t hate Zodiac like you did, but neither did I like it enough to want to go to the mattresses about it. I also agree on the massive writing failure at the end of Seraphim Falls. Breathtakingly lame. Although you and I differ about the film, up until then, which I thought was pretty taut and well-done by both principals.
    And I’ll second Sid. “Loosing” credibility? Fritz. Ouch.

  6. Team Donnybrook
    godonnybrook January 25, 2008 at 10:43 am · Reply

    The only film I saw on this list (luckily) was the number 23. It deserves to be on this list. I also saw Evan Almighty on the plane. Shit, that was a bad sequel.

  7. Truth January 25, 2008 at 10:46 am · Reply

    I think it was Sean Penn that said something about how, just like a great film can permanently change part of your life for the better, seeing a bad film can permanently diminish it. Makes you want to choose carefully, huh? Thanks for the lists.

  8. Col. Hector Bravado January 25, 2008 at 11:24 am · Reply

    Sometimes sequels can surpass the original, but what did you people expect from Evan Almighty 2? Really? The original was wipe.

  9. BadGirl88 October 23, 2009 at 7:24 am · Reply

    Many attributes of open science can be studied, including open access publications, open source code, open protocols, open proposals, open peer-review, open notebook science, open preprints, open licenses, open data, and the publishing of negative results. ,

Leave a Comment

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

comm comm comm